Renewing Trust: A Smarter Renewals Experience

Modernizing a messy, outdated flow to help users confidently renew their health plans.

Role

Lead UX Designer

Timeline

6 months

Platform

Responsive Web App

🧠 The Mess We Were Untangling

Renewals had become a frustrating black box.

Users with multiple plans (medical, dental) could only see one of their staged policies — creating confusion about what they were re-enrolling into. The outdated UI didn’t offer enough context or feedback, and as a result, customers didn’t trust the process. Worse, thousands of users were unintentionally opting out of their plans without realizing it.

💡 Our Big Idea

Give customers transparency, control, and just the right amount of reassurance.

We envisioned a cleaner, smarter renewals experience — one that surfaced all staged plans clearly, communicated progress, and helped customers feel confident about the outcome of their decisions.

✨ What We Built

  • A new Angular-based UI for the Renewals experience

  • A refreshed flow with better structure, more guidance, and built-in messaging

  • A display of the user's information on file to help them decide whether they needed to update anything, like income or address

  • A simple but powerful confirmation modal (“Are you sure?”) that prevented over 50,000 mistaken opt-outs

🧩 Our Challenges

This project had a lot of moving parts — technical limitations, legacy UI, and shifting priorities. One moment that stood out: discovering that the “Find New Plan” button caused critical data issues. We couldn’t remove it without losing functionality, but we also couldn’t leave it as-is.

Our compromise: relabel the button as “Shop for other plans,” while keeping the opt-out behavior in the backend. Not perfect — but a strategic tradeoff that reduced risk and met the user need.

Navigating those tensions required empathy, creativity, and collaboration.

👩‍💻 My Role

As Lead UX Designer, I drove the redesign process from end to end:

  • Led user interviews and journey mapping to understand renewal pain points

  • Partnered with product and development teams to define scope and explore constraints

  • Created wireframes, prototypes, and final UI in Figma

  • Balanced research-backed advocacy with pragmatic decision-making

  • Authored flow docs and a detailed nav map to support dev implementation

  • Completed full UX copy review to ensure tone clarity and reassurance across the experience

This project leaned heavily on my ability to be organized, process-driven, and fluent in both product and user language — especially when tradeoffs were on the table.

📈 The Results

  • 50,000+ users prevented from unintended opt-outs thanks to one simple modal

  • 83% of enrollments in 2025 came from returning customers, indicating that improving the renewal experience has significant business returns

  • A smoother, faster implementation process due to structured handoff documentation

👩‍🎓 What I Learned

  • Collaboration doesn’t mean compromise — it means staying flexible without losing sight of user needs.

  • In high-complexity projects, a journey map and nav flow doc are essential alignment tools.

  • Users want certainty. Our job is to surface the right info at the right moment so they don’t have to guess.

🧰 Skills This Project Showcases

✅ Designing with the dev reality in mind
✅ Using strategic storytelling to advocate for users when project scope tightened
✅ Writing content that builds trust in a high-stakes process
✅ Synthesizing user needs into clear, actionable experiences
✅ Organizing chaos with structure, clarity, and purpose

📎Artifacts

Want to see how I wrangled other messy systems?

Want to see how I wrangled other messy systems?

Libby Lippoth

Product Designer

Designing with heart, logic, and a really good to-do list.

Libby Lippoth

Product Designer

Designing with heart, logic, and a really good to-do list.

Libby Lippoth

Product Designer

Designing with heart, logic, and a really good to-do list.